Here are numerical examples with solutions for each method of estimating evapotranspiration (ET):
1. Pan Evaporation Method
Example:
Suppose a Class A evaporation pan is located near a crop field. The pan evaporation rate is measured to be 6 mm/day. The pan coefficient (Kp) for the area is 0.8.
Solution: The Pan Evaporation Method formula is used to estimate the reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) based on the evaporation rate from a Class A evaporation pan. The formula is:
Where:
- = Reference evapotranspiration (mm/day)
- = Pan coefficient (dimensionless)
- = Pan evaporation rate (mm/day)
Given data:
- Pan evaporation rate () = 6 mm/day
- Pan coefficient () = 0.8
Using the Pan Evaporation Method formula:
So, the estimated reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) using the Pan Evaporation Method is 4.8 mm/day.
2. Penman Method for Estimating Evapotranspiration
The Penman method estimates reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) by combining the effects of temperature, humidity, wind speed, and solar radiation. The Penman equation is:
The Penman-Monteith method is an advanced and widely accepted method for estimating reference evapotranspiration (ET₀). It combines various climatic parameters to provide a precise estimate. The FAO-56 Penman-Monteith equation is:
Where:
- = Slope of the saturation vapor pressure curve (kPa/°C)
- = Net radiation at the crop surface (MJ/m²/day)
- = Soil heat flux density (MJ/m²/day)
- = Psychrometric constant (kPa/°C)
- = Mean daily air temperature (°C)
- = Wind speed at 2 meters height (m/s)
- = Actual vapor pressure (kPa)
Numerical Example 1: Estimating ET₀ in a Warm Climate
Given Data:
- Net radiation () = 15 MJ/m²/day
- Soil heat flux density (G) = 0.0 MJ/m²/day (for daily estimates)
- Air density (ρa) = 1.225 kg/m³
- Specific heat of air (cp) = 0.001013 MJ/kg·K
- Saturation vapor pressure (es) = 3.2 kPa
- Actual vapor pressure (ea) = 2.0 kPa
- Wind speed (u) = 3.0 m/s
- Latent heat of vaporization (λ) = 2.45 MJ/kg
- Psychrometric constant (γ) = 0.066 kPa/°C
Assume the slope of the saturation vapor pressure curve (Δ) is 0.20 kPa/°C.
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the numerator:
=1.225×0.001013×1.2×1.224
=0.0033 (MJ/m²/day)
=3.0033 MJ/m²/day
- Calculate the denominator:
= 0.20+0.066×(1+2.453.0)
.20+0.066×(1+1.224)
.20+0.066×2.224=0.20+0.146
.346 kPa/°C
- Calculate ET₀:
=0.3463.0033
≈8.67 mm/day
Numerical Example 2: Estimating ET₀ in a Cooler Climate
Given Data:
- Net radiation (Rn) = 10 MJ/m²/day
- Soil heat flux density (G) = 0.0 MJ/m²/day (for daily estimates)
- Air density (ρa) = 1.225 kg/m³
- Specific heat of air (cp) = 0.001013 MJ/kg·K
- Saturation vapor pressure (es) = 1.8 kPa
- Actual vapor pressure (ea) = 1.2 kPa
- Wind speed (u) = 1.5 m/s
- Latent heat of vaporization (λ) = 2.45 MJ/kg
- Psychrometric constant (γ) = 0.066 kPa/°C
Assume the slope of the saturation vapor pressure curve (Δ) is 0.15 kPa/°C.
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the numerator:
, Δ⋅(Rn−G)=0.15×(10−0)=1.5
=1.225×0.001013×(1.8−1.2)×2.451.5
=1.225×0.001013×0.6×0.612
=0.00074 (MJ/m²/day)
Numerator=1.5+0.00074=1.50074 MJ/m²/day
- Calculate the denominator:
Δ+γ×(1+λu)
=0.15+0.066×(1+2.451.5)
=0.15+0.066×(1+0.612)
=0.15+0.066×1.612=0.15+0.106
=0.256 kPa/°C
- Calculate ET₀:
=0.2561.50074
≈5.86 mm/day
2. Penman-Monteith Method
Example:
Consider the following climatic data for a crop field:
- Net radiation (Rn) = 15 MJ/m²/day
- Soil heat flux density (G) = 0 MJ/m²/day
- Mean daily air temperature (T) = 25°C
- Wind speed at 2 m height (u2) = 3 m/s
- Saturation vapor pressure (es) = 3.2 kPa
- Actual vapor pressure (ea) = 2.1 kPa
- Psychrometric constant (γ) = 0.066 kPa/°C
- Slope of the vapor pressure curve (Δ) = 0.188 kPa/°C
Solution: To solve the given climatic data using the Penman-Monteith method for estimating reference evapotranspiration (ET₀), we use the FAO-56 Penman-Monteith equation:
Given data:
- Net radiation () = 15 MJ/m²/day
- Soil heat flux density () = 0 MJ/m²/day
- Mean daily air temperature () = 25°C
- Wind speed at 2 m height () = 3 m/s
- Saturation vapor pressure () = 3.2 kPa
- Actual vapor pressure () = 2.1 kPa
- Psychrometric constant () = 0.066 kPa/°C
- Slope of the vapor pressure curve () = 0.188 kPa/°C
Let's solve the equation step by step.
Step 1: Calculate the first term of the numerator
=0.408×0.188×15
=1.14936 mm/day
Step 2: Calculate the second term of the numerator
=0.066×3.02×3×1.1
Step 3: Sum the terms of the numerator
1.80636 mm/day
Step 4: Calculate the denominator
=0.188+0.066(1+1.02)
=0.188+0.13332
Step 5: Calculate ET₀
So, the estimated reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) using the Penman-Monteith method is approximately 5.62 mm/day.
Numerical Example 1: Estimating ET₀ in a Warm Climate
Given Data:
- Mean daily temperature () = 25°C
- Net radiation () = 15 MJ/m²/day
- Soil heat flux density () = 0.0 MJ/m²/day
- Wind speed () = 3 m/s
- Saturation vapor pressure () = 3.2 kPa
- Actual vapor pressure () = 2.0 kPa
- Psychrometric constant () = 0.066 kPa/°C
- Slope of the saturation vapor pressure curve () = 0.188 kPa/°C
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the first term of the numerator:
- Calculate the second term of the numerator:
= 0.066×3.02×3×1.2
.715164 mm/day- Sum the terms of the numerator:
1.863804 mm/day
- Calculate the denominator:
=0.188+0.066(1+1.02)
=0.32132 kPa/°C
- Calculate ET₀:
≈5.80 mm/day
Numerical Example 2: Estimating ET₀ in a Cooler Climate
Given Data:
- Mean daily temperature () = 15°C
- Net radiation () = 10 MJ/m²/day
- Soil heat flux density () = 0.0 MJ/m²/day
- Wind speed (u2) = 2 m/s
- Saturation vapor pressure (es) = 1.7 kPa
- Actual vapor pressure (ea) = 1.0 kPa
- Psychrometric constant (γ) = 0.066 kPa/°C
- Slope of the saturation vapor pressure curve (Δ) = 0.143 kPa/°C
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the first term of the numerator:
=0.408×0.143×10
=0.58464 mm/day- Calculate the second term of the numerator:
=0.066×3.125×2×0.7
=0.066×4.375
=0.28875 mm/day
- Sum the terms of the numerator:
=0.87339 mm/day
- Calculate the denominator:
0.25388 kPa/°C- Calculate ET₀:
≈3.44 mm/day
3. Blaney-Criddle Method for Estimating Evapotranspiration
The Blaney-Criddle method is a practical and widely used approach for estimating reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) based on temperature and daylight hours. The formula is given by:
Where:
- o = Reference evapotranspiration (mm/day)
- = Mean daily percentage of annual daytime hours
- = Mean daily temperature (°C)
Numerical Example 1: Estimating ET₀ for a Summer Month
Given Data:
- Mean daily temperature (T) = 25°C
- Mean daily percentage of annual daytime hours (p) = 0.30 (for a specific location and time of the year)
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the product of the mean daily temperature and the coefficient 0.46:
- Add 8.13 to the above result:
- Multiply the result by the mean daily percentage of annual daytime hours (p):
- Round to a practical precision:
ET0≈5.89 mm/day
So, the estimated reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) for the summer month is 5.89 mm/day.
Numerical Example 2: Estimating ET₀ for a Winter Month
Given Data:
- Mean daily temperature (T) = 10°C
- Mean daily percentage of annual daytime hours (p) = 0.15 (for a specific location and time of the year)
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the product of the mean daily temperature and the coefficient 0.46:
- Add 8.13 to the above result:
- Multiply the result by the mean daily percentage of annual daytime hours (p):
- Round to a practical precision:
ET0≈1.91 mm/day
So, the estimated reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) for the winter month is 1.91 mm/day.
4. Hargreaves Method
Example:
Assume you have the following data for a crop field:
- Mean daily temperature (Tmean) = 22°C
- Maximum daily temperature (Tmax) = 30°C
- Minimum daily temperature (Tmin) = 15°C
- Extraterrestrial radiation (Ra) = 25 MJ/m²/day
Solution: To estimate the reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) using the Hargreaves method, we will use the following formula:
ET0=0.0023×(Tmean+17.8)×(Tmax−Tmin)0.5×Ra
Given data:
- Mean daily temperature () = 22°C
- Maximum daily temperature () = 30°C
- Minimum daily temperature () = 15°C
- Extraterrestrial radiation () = 25 MJ/m²/day
Step-by-Step Solution:
- Calculate the temperature difference and its square root:
- Apply the Hargreaves equation:
ET0=0.0023×(Tmean+17.8)×(Tmax−Tmin)0.5×Ra
ET0=0.0023×(22+17.8)×3.87×25
- Simplify the equation step-by-step:
ET0=0.0023×39.8×3.87×25
ET0=0.0023×39.8×96.75
ET0=0.0023×3850.05
ET0≈8.86 mm/day
So, the estimated reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) for the given data using the Hargreaves method is approximately 8.86 mm/day.
Numerical Example 1: Estimating ET₀ in a Warm Climate
Given Data:
- Mean daily temperature () = 25°C
- Maximum daily temperature () = 35°C
- Minimum daily temperature () = 15°C
- Extraterrestrial radiation () = 20 MJ/m²/day
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the temperature difference and its square root:
- Apply the Hargreaves equation:
ET0=0.0023×(25+17.8)×4.47×20
- Simplify the equation step-by-step:
ET0≈8.80 mm/day
So, the estimated reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) for the warm climate is 8.80 mm/day.
Numerical Example 2: Estimating ET₀ in a Cooler Climate
Given Data:
- Mean daily temperature () = 10°C
- Maximum daily temperature () = 15°C
- Minimum daily temperature () = 5°C
- Extraterrestrial radiation () = 15 MJ/m²/day
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the temperature difference and its square root:
,
- Apply the Hargreaves equation:
ET0=0.0023×(Tmean+17.8)×(Tmax−Tmin)0.5×Ra
- Simplify the equation step-by-step:
So, the estimated reference evapotranspiration (ET₀) for the cooler climate is 3.03 mm/day.
5. Thornthwaite Method
Thornthwaite Method for Estimating Evapotranspiration
The Thornthwaite method estimates potential evapotranspiration (ET₀) primarily based on temperature and day length. This method is suitable for use when only temperature data is available. The Thornthwaite equation is:
ET0=16(I10⋅T)a
Where:
- ET0 = Potential evapotranspiration (mm/month)
- T = Mean monthly temperature (°C)
- I = Heat index, calculated as the sum of monthly heat indices for the year
- a = Empirical exponent, calculated using the equation:
a=(6.75×10−7)I3−(7.71×10−5)I2+(1.792×10−2)I+0.49239
Step-by-Step Calculation:
Calculate the Monthly Heat Index (i):
Calculate the Annual Heat Index (I):
Calculate the Empirical Exponent (a):
= (6.75×10−7)I3−(7.71×10−5)I2+(1.792×10−2)I+0.49239
Calculate the Monthly ET₀:
Numerical Example 1: Estimating ET₀ in a Warm Climate
Given Data:
- Mean monthly temperature (T) = 25°C for each month
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the Monthly Heat Index (i):
- Calculate the Annual Heat Index (I):
Since the temperature is the same each month:
I=12×11.77=141.24
- Calculate the Empirical Exponent (a):
a=(6.75×10−7)I3−(7.71×10−5)I2+(1.792×10−2)I+0.49239
a=(6.75×10−7)(141.24)3−(7.71×10−5)(141.24)2+(1.792×10−2)(141.24)+0.49239
a≈0.0131
- Calculate the Monthly ET₀:
ET0≈16.2 mm/month
So, the estimated potential evapotranspiration (ET₀) for the warm climate is 16.2 mm/month.
Numerical Example 2: Estimating ET₀ in a Cooler Climate
Given Data:
- Mean monthly temperature (T) = 10°C for each month
Steps to Solve:
- Calculate the Monthly Heat Index (i):
i=(5T)1.514,
i=(510)1.514,
i=21.514
i≈2.86
- Calculate the Annual Heat Index (I):
Since the temperature is the same each month:
- Calculate the Empirical Exponent (a):
a=(6.75×10−7)I3−(7.71×10−5)I2+(1.792×10−2)I+0.49239
a≈0.498
- Calculate the Monthly ET₀: